NHL

The San Jose Sharks’ Rebuild Still Has Major Problems to Address

The Sharks' rebuild still has problems to address.

The San Jose Sharks have invested heavily in young talent, but their early-season struggles show that the rebuild is far from finished. Macklin Celebrini has become the face of the franchise, but the Sharks still have several problems to address before they can become a playoff team. If the organization wants to take the next step, it cannot keep ignoring the weaknesses in its roster.

Through 23 games of the 2026-27 NHL season, San Jose has a 10-11-2 record and sits fourth in the Pacific Division. The team has allowed 81 goals while scoring just 63. With a -18 goal differential and 3.52 goals against per game, it’s clear that defense remains a major problem. Those numbers are simply not good enough for a team hoping to compete for a playoff spot.

General manager Mike Grier has made progress with the rebuild, but adding young talent is not enough. The Sharks need better defense, more consistent scoring, and a team that can compete even when Celebrini is not producing. Grier needs to start making moves that address these problems instead of continuing to rely on potential.

Defense Must Become a Priority in Sharks’ Rebuild

For much of the rebuild, San Jose has focused on developing offensive talent. Celebrini has become the centerpiece, while Will Smith and Michael Misa give the organization more young offensive potential.

However, the defensive side of the roster needs great improvement. Allowing 3.52 goals per game will make it difficult to compete with the better teams in the Western Conference. The Sharks cannot expect their offense to bail them out every night, especially against teams with stronger defensive groups.

Sam Dickinson could become an important part of the Sharks’ future on defense. The former first-round pick has plenty of potential, but San Jose needs to make sure he develops properly instead of giving him too much responsibility too early. Rushing his development would be a mistake, especially when the team already has so many defensive problems.

The Sharks also have experienced defensemen such as Darnell Nurse, Dmitry Orlov, and Jacob Trouba. Their experience can help, but the organization still needs to find the right balance between veterans and younger players. Simply having veteran defensemen does not mean the defensive problems are solved.

Simon Edvinsson Could Be an Intriguing Target

One player that should rightly tempt San Jose is disgruntled Detroit Red Wings defenseman Simon Edvinsson.

At 23 years old and standing 6-foot-6, Edvinsson has the size and skill to become an important addition to the Sharks’ defense. During the 2025-26 season, he recorded nine goals and 16 assists for 25 points in 72 games while averaging 22:21 of ice time.

Edvinsson has already shown that he can handle major NHL responsibilities. Adding a young defenseman with his experience could help San Jose improve while also giving the organization another player to build around. He is exactly the type of player the Sharks should be looking to acquire, rather than spending their resources on short-term solutions.

His contract situation is another reason to monitor him. Edvinsson entered the 2026 offseason as a restricted free agent and has yet to agree to a new deal with Detroit. The Red Wings have maintained that signing him is a priority, although they are reportedly willing to listen to trade calls.

The opportunity to sign a top-line defenceman might be too costly given what Detroit would want in return. Still, the fit is too good not to give serious consideration. If Grier is serious about fixing the defense, Edvinsson should be one of the players at the top of his list.

The Sharks Attack Needs More Than Celebrini

Celebrini has been San Jose’s most important offensive player. Through 21 games played, he has recorded nine goals and 18 assists for 27 points. However, one player cannot carry an entire team. The Sharks need more production from the rest of their forward group.

Smith has recorded eight goals and 10 assists for 18 points in 23 games. His development will be important because San Jose needs another reliable offensive threat alongside Celebrini. Smith needs to become more consistent if the Sharks want to take pressure off their superstar.

Misa and the other young forwards also need to continue developing. The Sharks have a talented young core; however, that won’t be enough. Celebrini will continue to draw opponents’ best defenders. Without adding worthy top-line-level talent, there isn’t enough to take advantage.

The Sharks cannot build an entire offense around Celebrini and expect everyone else to figure things out. They need more players who can create scoring chances and take advantage of opportunities when Celebrini is being shut down.

2026 11 16T011152Z 1701341514 MT1USATODAY30362885 RTRMADP 3 NHL NASHVILLE PREDATORS AT SAN JOSE SHARKS scaled
Nov 15, 2026; San Jose, California, USA; San Jose Sharks center Macklin Celebrini (71) celebrates with the bench after scoring during the third period against the Nashville Predators at SAP Center at San Jose. Mandatory Credit: Justine Willard-Imagn Images

What Needs to Happen Next

The Sharks do not need to restart their rebuild, but they need to make improvements. Their young offensive core gives them plenty of reasons to be optimistic, but their defensive problems cannot continue. At some point, potential needs to turn into results.

Grier should focus on three things moving forward: improving the defense, getting more consistent production from the supporting forwards, and establishing a stronger team identity.

The Sharks have a promising attack with Celebrini, Smith, Misa, and Dickinson. However, they still need the right players around them. Grier cannot afford to waste the opportunity this young core provides by failing to address the team’s biggest weaknesses.

Until San Jose becomes more reliable defensively and gets more contributions from its entire lineup, the rebuild will continue to take time. As LWOS has previously discussed regarding Celebrini’s rise, the young superstar gives this franchise something to build around. Now Grier needs to make sure the rest of the roster can keep up.

 

Main Image: Justine Willard-Imagn Images