The Ohio State Buckeyes find themselves in a familiar yet precarious position as they prepare for the College Football Playoff (CFP). After a stellar 12-0 regular season, the Buckeyes stumbled in the Big Ten Championship game, falling to the Indiana Hoosiers 13-10 in a low-scoring affair that exposed a glaring issue: a troubling inability to finish drives in the red zone.
Despite the loss, Ohio State secured the No. 2 seed in the expanded CFP and a coveted first-round bye, setting up a quarterfinal matchup in the Cotton Bowl against the winner of the Miami–Texas A&M game. The current storyline shifts from a flawless pursuit of a title to a narrative of redemption, focusing squarely on whether head coach Ryan Day and the offense can solve their red-zone inefficiency before their championship dreams are derailed.
Ohio State’s Red Zone Woes and the Road to Redemption
The Big Ten Championship Blunder: A Cause for Concern
The loss to Indiana was a bitter pill to swallow for the Buckeyes, not just because it snapped a 16-game winning streak dating back to the previous season, but because of how they lost. The defense was characteristically dominant, smothering the Hoosiers’ offense for much of the game. The offense, led by Heisman finalist quarterback Julian Sayin, moved the ball effectively, gaining 258 yards through the air against a tough Indiana defense. The problem, however, was scoring.
Ohio State went two-for-four in red-zone opportunities, managing only one touchdown. A late game sequence perfectly encapsulated the issues: trailing by three points, the Buckeyes had two drives of over 70 yards each deep into Indiana territory but came away with zero points. One promising drive ended in an overturned call on a fourth-down run, while another concluded with a missed field goal. These failures to convert scoring opportunities into touchdowns have raised a significant worry that had been “swept under the rug” during earlier, higher-scoring victories.
Potential Solutions: Day Reclaims Play-Calling, Talent Infusion
The immediate fallout from the loss has prompted discussions about critical changes the team needs to consider before the CFP. Day is facing pressure to reclaim play-calling duties for the playoff run, an indication that the current approach under offensive coordinator Brian Hartline may need adjustment. The offensive line also had its worst game of the season against Indiana, allowing five sacks after giving up only six during the entire 12-game regular season. Improvement there is paramount to give Sayin time to operate.
Despite these immediate concerns, the Buckeyes remain a national championship betting favorite due to their immense talent. The receiving corps, featuring elite talents like Jeremiah Smith and Carnell Tate, is a primary strength that can be leveraged for red-zone breakthroughs. While speaking of talented Ohio State receivers, the recent re-affirmation of commitment from five-star wide receiver recruit Chris Henry Jr., a top prospect for the 2026 class, provides further good news for the long-term future and helps the Buckeyes avoid needing a wide receiver in the transfer portal.
The Path Ahead: Redemption in the Cotton Bowl
Ohio State’s path to defending its 2024 national title involves focusing on these correctable issues during their bye week. The players, like Sayin, have spoken about moving past the loss and focusing on preparation for the CFP run. The story of redemption has been a theme for the Buckeyes since late season, especially after the adversity and doubt faced following the previous year’s loss to “that team up north”.
The Buckeyes will play the winner of the Texas A&M and Miami game in the Cotton Bowl Classic on December 31. This break gives Day and his staff time to diagnose and fix the offensive finishing issues. If the Buckeyes can successfully address their red-zone inefficiency and protect their quarterback, their elite defense and high-end talent could still power them to a second consecutive national championship. The narrative has shifted from an unblemished march to an opportunity for a resilient comeback, and all eyes will be on the Buckeyes to see if they can write the perfect final chapter to their season.
Main Image: Samantha Madar/Columbus Dispatch / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images
