The New York Giants have made one of the most impactful decisions in the young 2025 NFL season, naming first-round rookie Jaxson Dart as their starting quarterback for Week 4 against the Los Angeles Chargers. This move signals a significant shift in the Giants’ approach and reflects both the struggles of veteran Russell Wilson and the confidence the coaching staff has in their young signal-caller’s potential. Will this be the move that turns their season around?
New York Giants Turn to Rookie Quarterback Jaxson Dart
The Context: Russell Wilson’s Struggles and the Giants’ 0-3 Start
The Giants enter Week 4 winless at 0-3, and the offensive struggles have been a major factor. While the veteran Wilson was brought in to provide a stable presence, his performance has been underwhelming.
The offensive output in two of the first three games was unpleasant, to say the least. The Week 3 loss to the Kansas City Chiefs, where Wilson struggled in the red zone and capped off a poor performance with an ill-advised throw, further highlighted the offensive struggles. The decision to transition to Dart reflects a belief that Wilson is a shell of his former self.
Why Now? Jaxson Dart’s Readiness and Potential
Despite the team’s initial intention for Dart to take his time developing, the urgency created by the 0-3 start and Wilson’s poor play has accelerated the timeline. Sources close to the team indicate that Dart has consistently met every benchmark set by coach Brian Daboll and the staff.
He demonstrated rapid learning and strong performance in the offseason and training camp. His preseason performances showcased quick decision-making and precise ball placement. Furthermore, Dart is described as being tough and possessing the mobility that gives the Giants a better chance to win games now, even with the expected rookie mistakes.
Impact and Future Outlook
The decision to start Dart carries significant weight for the Giants’ organization. The futures of both coach Daboll and general manager Joe Schoen are tied to Dart’s success. The immediate pressure on Dart is immense, as the Giants are hoping he can spark the offense and turn the season around. The Chargers are off to a 3-0 start and present a formidable challenge for the young quarterback, as they have been one of the top defenses in the entire league through three weeks of the season.
The shift to a rookie quarterback comes with inherent risks, but the Giants believe the upside with Dart outweighs the stagnation with Wilson. The team’s success will likely hinge on Dart’s ability to quickly adapt to the speed and complexity of the NFL. The upcoming Week 4 matchup will provide the first real test of whether the Giants’ gamble on their rookie signal-caller will pay off.
The move also opens up opportunities for other offensive players to thrive, particularly if Dart can elevate the passing game. The performance of players like Malik Nabers, who has yet to find a consistent rhythm this season, could see dramatic improvement as soon as this week. The Giants are hopeful that by leaning on a strong run game led by Cam Skattebo and finding ways to simplify the passing game for Dart, they can create an environment where he can develop and succeed.
The next few weeks will be crucial for the Giants. The success or failure of their season, and potentially the careers of their head coach and general manager, rests heavily on the shoulders of their new starting quarterback, Dart. Whether he can deliver on the promise he has shown and provide the spark the Giants desperately need remains to be seen.
Main Image: Kevin Jairaj-Imagn Images
