New York Jets General Manager Darren Mougey believes Justin Fields’ journey may be following a path similar to that of Baker Mayfield and Sam Darnold—two quarterbacks who faced early-career struggles but eventually found success after a change of scenery. Fields has been bounced around recently, going from Chicago to Pittsburgh, and now ending up with the Jets. Chicago had ups and downs throughout its tenure, while Pittsburgh never really gave him the full reins. In a recent statement, Mougey said he sees a blueprint that Fields could follow, pointing out how both Mayfield and Darnold were able to reinvent their careers in more stable environments. 

“Guys like Sam and Baker, they needed a fresh start, time to grow, and the right structure,” Mougey explained. “I believe Justin can be one of those guys.”

Jets GM Believes His QB Can Follow Mayfield–Darnold Path

Context and Growth

Fields enters his third team in as many years, having played under a different offensive coordinator each season since being drafted in 2021. That type of turnover would be hard for any quarterback. Learning a new playbook is like learning a new language, depending on how different the schemes are for the coaching staffs being brought in.

Mix the learning aspect with the fact he has to also teach it to the rest of his teammates and learn not only his position but everyone else’s assignments too. This constant turnover has made consistency and development difficult, but Mougey is confident that things are changing in New York. He noted that Fields is showing encouraging signs during training camp, from improved leadership to stronger command of the offense. 

Locked-In Role and Support

Fields isn’t competing for the starting job; he already has it. The Jets have committed to him as their QB1 for the 2025 season, giving him a two-year, $40 million contract with $30 million guaranteed. Giving him that level of commitment and not having to look over his shoulder can do wonders for his development. He hasn’t had that level of trust since his rookie season. Giving him the keys could free him up to just play his game with no worries.

This level of clarity and support is a critical shift for Fields, who dealt with uncertainty during much of his time in Chicago. Now, with a defined role and coaching staff committed to his growth, the Jets believe they’ve created a situation where he can finally flourish.

Drawing Parallels

The comparisons to Mayfield and Darnold are fitting. Both quarterbacks were labeled busts early in their careers before finding success in later opportunities. Mayfield led Tampa Bay to a playoff berth and had over 4,000 passing yards with 40+ passing touchdowns just a year ago. Darnold reinvented himself as a competent starter in a more balanced system under Coach O’Connell in Minnesota. The funny part about it all is that both Mayfield and Darnold were teammates in Carolina, both vying for playing time, ultimately getting cut. Fields has the talent to do the same, but with arguably a higher ceiling due to his athleticism and dual-threat attack. 

Mougey’s belief isn’t based on blind optimism. Fields has shown flashes throughout the years of his playmaking ability and his ability to push the ball down the field with his arm. Sometimes players need a change of scenery and a team that believes in them to get the first version of themselves they can be. With improved offensive line play, emerging skill position players, and a coach willing to play to his strengths, Fields has the pieces to turn things around.

The Stakes and the Opportunity

What makes Fields’ opportunity in New York so pivotal is the combination of timing, patience, and team structure. The Jets are not expecting instant perfection, in fact, they aren’t looking for anything near perfect. All they want is progress. Show some signs of development and leadership to steer this franchise back into the right direction after years of turmoil. They believe that if Fields continues his upward trajectory, he could stabilize the position for a franchise that’s been searching for a long-term solution for years.

Now, is this false hope, or is this a GM trying to be a half glass full guy instead of half glass empty when it comes to seeing what they have in their current quarterback? There is plenty of reason to doubt this working out. Very rare do players strike lightning in a bottle after being on their third team in only five years.

As of late, there’s been more exceptions to the rule rather than what’s the norm. All the Jets can do is continue to put their belief in Fields and see what they have. If it doesn’t work out, they can’t say they didn’t try, and whoever the next quarterback may be should feel comfortable knowing that this front office/coaching staff has their best interest at heart. 

Conclusion 

It would be irresponsible to assume that Fields is going to be the next quarterback to break out after years of disappointment, in the likes of Geno Smith, Darnold, and Mayfield. Nobody is saying for sure that Fields will be or won’t be, but letting Fields go out there and play his game will be crucial for making this notion come to fruition. 

It’s still early, and challenges remain. But if Fields can capitalize on the stability and trust he now has, his story could mirror those of Mayfield and Darnold—quarterbacks who were written off too soon, only to remind everyone that development isn’t always linear.

Main Image: Rich Barnes-Imagn Images