In a surprising move, Penn State has officially dismissed longtime head coach James Franklin. The decision arrives after a series of disappointing performances that derailed what had begun as a season filled with high expectations.
Penn State Fires Head Coach James Franklin
A Tumultuous Finish
Franklin’s firing followed a three-game losing streak that triggered a rapid unraveling of the season’s promise. The slide began with an overtime defeat at home to Oregon which was a game many viewed as winnable, though Oregon is among the nation’s elite programs. What ultimately sealed Franklin’s fate were consecutive losses to UCLA and Northwestern, two teams Penn State was expected to outperform.
Compounding the issue was inconsistency in earlier games. The Nittany Lions flirted with disaster against lesser non-conference opponents, failing to convincingly close out matchups they should have controlled. Meanwhile, the development of quarterback Drew Allar—once heralded as a five-star talent—never fully materialized under Franklin, further undermining confidence. With the program tumbling out of the AP Top 25, the administration opted for a clean break.
Franklin’s Buyout Among the Largest in College Football History
James Franklin’s departure from Penn State doesn’t just mark the end of an era and it comes with a staggering financial cost. The university is on the hook for approximately $49 million, making it the second-largest coaching buyout in college football history, only behind Jimbo Fisher’s $76 million payout from Texas A&M. Franklin signed a 10-year contract extension in 2021, which includes guaranteed annual compensation through 2031.
However, Penn State may not be on the line for the full amount. The deal includes a “duty to mitigate” clause, meaning any future income Franklin earns — whether through coaching, media, or other employment — could reduce the amount the university ultimately owes. Still, the buyout reflects just how far expectations and reality drifted apart in what was once seen as a long-term partnership.
A Track Record of Recovery and Success
Despite the disappointing exit, Franklin’s record at Penn State cannot be dismissed lightly. When he arrived, the program was in the throes of recovery, still dealing with the institutional fallout of the Paterno/Sandusky scandal. Over the course of his tenure, Franklin presided over multiple seasons with double-digit wins, delivered a Big Ten championship, and routinely finished within the upper half of national rankings.
He also built a recruiting pipeline and established a program identity that attracted talent and attention. Franklin often earned credit for restoring stability, rebuild momentum, and for positioning Penn State as a consistent presence in the national conversation.
The Pressure Mounts
Still, success breeds expectations and over time, those expectations became crushing. Each year, Penn State’s fans and administrators demanded more than winning seasons; they wanted dominance against powerhouses like Ohio State and Michigan. Franklin’s inability to consistently close that gap increasingly frustrated stakeholders.
As losses to elite programs accumulated, patience thinned. Criticism grew louder about Franklin’s in-game decision-making and ability to develop quarterbacks. The gap between perception and results widened. For a blue-blood program with robust resources and high aspirations, the weight of unmet expectations proved decisive.
Main Image: James Lang-Imagn Images
